What It Is
The execution in the square at Cesena is the driest scene in the book: the minister who pacified the Romagna in Cesare Borgia's name is put in two pieces one morning, in the square, with a block of wood and a bloody knife beside him, so that the people may see that the cruelty was the minister's and not the prince's. The book tells it without an adjective of approval or of horror, and it is this dryness that makes it a symbol: of a prince who uses violence as an instrument, hands it to another and removes it from his own name.
Ramiro de Lorqua (in Italian, Ramiro d'Orco), governor of the Romagna for Cesare Borgia, was executed at Cesena in December 1502, shortly before Sinigaglia.
Where It Appears
The scene is in Chapter VII. The Romagna was full of robberies and quarrels, commanded by weak lords, and Cesare put at its head messer Ramiro d'Orco, a cruel and efficient man, with full powers, and the region became peaceful. Fearing the hatred for so much severity, he set up a civil tribunal and showed that the cruelty was the minister's.
he had him placed one morning in two pieces, at Cesena, in the square, with a block of wood and a bloody knife beside him. The ferocity of that spectacle left those peoples at once satisfied and stunned.
Machiavelli does not comment on the execution and passes at once to the next subject. The next chapter, Chapter VIII, returns the same tone in another scene of betrayal: the banquet at which Oliverotto of Fermo has his uncle and the citizens who received him killed. And Chapter XVII gives the result, by recalling that Cesare's cruelty restored order to the Romagna, uniting it and bringing it to peace and loyalty.
that cruelty of his had restored order to the Romagna, united it and brought it to peace and loyalty
What It Means
The scene means that a prince's violence is governed: it has a time, an instrument and a destination. Cesare uses Ramiro twice, first as a hard hand, to pacify without dirtying himself, then as the culprit, to clear the hatred that the hardness bred. The spectacle leaves the peoples at once satisfied and stunned: satisfied to see the hated man punished, stunned to see what the prince can do. What Machiavelli describes is the effect, and the reader decides what to think.
The text supports two readings. In one, the scene is a technique of government: the prince who needs a hard hand and then a culprit, and that is exactly what the book records, a rule about the distribution of hatred. In the other, the scene is a theater of power, the body exposed as a message, and what it says is less about Ramiro than about the spectator. Both fit, and the book leaves them without comment, which makes Cesena the symbol of the coldness of the method and not of its justice.
Relationships
- Standard themes: Violence, Power, Politics, Appearance and Reality.
- Characters: Cesare Borgia, who orders it, and Machiavelli, who narrates it without comment.
- Neighboring symbols: the fox and the lion, the image in which force and fraud work together.