Who He Is
Agathocles is the ancient the book chooses to show the path of crime: the Sicilian born of a potter who always led a wicked life, but accompanied it with so much virtù of spirit and of body that he rose through the militia to praetor of Syracuse. Chapter VIII presents him as an example of one who comes to a principality without fortune and without virtù in the full sense, and Machiavelli tells it without discussing the merits, because the example is enough for anyone who might be obliged to imitate him. What he wants is to be prince and to hold by force what had been granted him by agreement. What he knows is how to prepare the blow with an ally, to gather the people and the Senate as if to deliberate and to kill them all at once. What the book says of him is that, for courage and greatness of spirit, there is no reason why he should be held inferior to a most excellent captain, but that crime gives empire, not glory.
Agathocles (361-289 BC) seized power in Syracuse in 317 BC and invaded Africa in 310 BC, during the war with Carthage.
Trajectory
Chapter VIII tells his life in order. He is born of a potter and always leads a wicked life, accompanied by virtù of spirit and of body, and rises through the ranks of the militia to praetor of Syracuse. Decided to be prince and to hold by violence what had been granted him by agreement, he arranges the plan with Hamilcar, the Carthaginian general who was making war in Sicily. One morning he gathers the people and the Senate as if to deliberate on the Republic and, at a signal, has his soldiers kill all the senators and the richest. He then occupies the principality without civil controversy, and, though twice defeated by the Carthaginians and besieged, he defends the city, attacks Africa and forces them to leave him Sicily.
Machiavelli judges the man in two stages. First he recognizes that there is no reason why he should be held inferior to any most excellent captain.
there is no reason why he should be held inferior to any most excellent captain
Then he sets the limit: to kill one's own citizens, betray friends, be without faith, without pity, without religion cannot be called virtù, and these ways can win one empire, but not glory.
Yet it cannot be called virtù to kill one's own citizens, betray friends, be without faith, without pity, without religion; these ways can win one empire, but not glory.
The chapter closes with the problem Agathocles poses: how did he and others like him live secure, when so many could not keep the state even in peacetime? The answer is that cruelties can be well or badly used, and Agathocles' were of the kind committed all at once, out of the necessity of securing oneself. Chapter VII brings the modern case of one who rises by others' arms and Chapter IX passes to the other path, that of the civil principality.
Themes Embodied
Agathocles embodies Violence in its purest form in the book, crime as a way of access to power, and Chapter VIII uses him to teach that it is measured by dose and by moment, not by the mere fact of existing. He embodies Virtù in a technical sense, the courage and greatness of spirit of the captain, which the book recognizes without confusing it with goodness. And he touches honor and reputation, because the glory that crime does not give is the point at which Machiavelli separates empire, which Agathocles obtained, from praise, which he did not.
The text supports two readings of the same man. In one, he is the excellent captain, who enters and leaves dangers and endures reverses like any great leader. In the other, he is the wicked man, whom crime strips of the title of virtuous, although it leaves him power. Machiavelli resolves the paradox by separating the two things and treating each in turn: competence and wickedness. The reader notices that he does not deny Agathocles' success, he denies the title, and that the chapter exists to teach a rule of measure, when and how evil can last.
Relationships
- Francesco Sforza: the contrast of Chapter VII and Chapter VIII, the one who rose by virtù and held with little effort, set against the one who rose by crime and won empire without glory.
- Cesare Borgia: the modern who, in Chapter VIII, kills Oliverotto at Sinigaglia; Chapter VII and Chapter VIII are the two chapters of the rise by fortune and the rise by crime.
- Machiavelli: the author who tells the case with neither applause nor horror, and who chooses the example because it is enough for anyone who might be obliged to imitate him.